5 Ways Small Businesses Get Robbed by People They Trust

By Justin Hanson, CPA, CFE

When most owners picture fraud, they picture a hacker or a stranger. But in my work as a Certified Fraud Examiner, the person behind it is almost always someone the owner knows well: a long-time bookkeeper, an office manager, a trusted employee who "handles everything."

The numbers back this up. According to the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners' 2024 Report to the Nations, organizations lose an estimated 5% of revenue to fraud each year. At companies with fewer than 100 employees, the median loss per case is $141,000, and the typical scheme runs for 12 months before anyone catches it.

Small businesses aren't targeted because their people are less honest. They're targeted because trust often stands in for controls. One person opens the mail, deposits the checks, pays the bills and reconciles the bank account, and nobody looks over their shoulder because nobody thinks they need to.

Here are the five schemes the ACFE found are more common in small businesses than in large ones, and what you can do about each.

1. Fake or inflated vendor bills

Billing schemes showed up in 31% of small-business fraud cases. An employee sets up a vendor that doesn't exist (often with a name close to a real one), or a real vendor overbills with an inside partner's help, and the payments go out like any other bill.

Warning signs: vendors you don't recognize, invoices with no phone number or a P.O. box address, round-dollar amounts, or one person who both adds vendors and approves payments.

Safeguard: have the owner review the vendor list every quarter, and require a second person to approve any new vendor or change to a vendor's bank details.

2. Check and payment tampering

This appeared in 23% of small-business cases, more than double the rate at larger companies. It includes forged or altered checks, payments made out to the employee instead of the vendor, and electronic payments redirected to a personal account.

Warning signs: missing check numbers, cleared checks payable to someone other than who's in the books, and bank statements nobody but the bookkeeper ever sees.

Safeguard: have bank statements go directly to the owner (or give the owner online view access), and look at cleared check images each month. The person who writes checks should not be the one who reconciles the bank account.

3. Padded expense reimbursements

Expense schemes appeared in 20% of small-business cases. Personal meals billed as client lunches, the same receipt submitted twice, mileage that was never driven, or business card charges for personal purchases.

Warning signs: expense totals that creep up over time, missing receipts, "miscellaneous" charges, or round numbers on mileage logs.

Safeguard: a written expense policy, receipts required for every charge, and a monthly review of company card statements by someone other than the cardholder.

4. Skimming cash before it's recorded

Skimming showed up in 19% of small-business cases. Because the money is taken before the sale ever hits the books, there's no record of it to reconcile. It's common anywhere customers pay in cash or by check at the front desk.

Warning signs: sales or collections that drop when one particular person is working, customers who say they paid but show a balance, and deposits made late or in irregular amounts.

Safeguard: issue receipts for every payment, separate the person who takes payments from the person who records them, and compare daily deposits to your scheduling or point-of-sale records.

5. Payroll padding and ghost employees

Payroll fraud appeared in 14% of small-business cases. It ranges from inflated hours and unapproved overtime to "ghost" employees: former staff left on payroll or people who never worked there at all.

Warning signs: names on the payroll register you don't recognize, two employees sharing a bank account, or overtime that only one person approves.

Safeguard: the owner reviews the payroll register before each run, and changes to pay rates or direct-deposit accounts need a second approval. Remove departing employees from payroll on their last day.

Trust your people, and verify the numbers

None of this means you should suspect everyone who works for you. Most employees are honest, and good controls protect them too, because when something goes wrong, clear records show who did and didn't touch the money.

The common thread in all five schemes is one person controlling a process from start to finish with no one else checking. You don't need a big accounting department to fix that. A few habits go a long way:

  • Have more than one person involved in handling money, recording it and reconciling it.

  • Read your own bank and credit card statements every month.

  • Review your vendor list and payroll register regularly.

  • Let your team know someone outside the business reviews the books. The ACFE found that 43% of frauds are uncovered by tips, and simply knowing someone is looking discourages most schemes before they start.

At Bridge Accounting Solutions, every client's books are reviewed under the eye of a CPA and Certified Fraud Examiner. If you'd like a second set of eyes on your business, we'd be glad to help.

Book a Discovery Call

Sources:

Previous
Previous

From Nurse to Numbers: What do Nursing and Accounting Have in Common?

Next
Next

What Does a Fractional CFO Do for a Growing Business in St. Tammany Parish?